The Supreme Court of India has nullified the ₹202 crore fine levied by the Competition Commission of India (CCI) on Amazon for allegedly concealing vital information regarding its acquisition of a 49 percent stake in Future Coupons Private Limited (FCPL). The judgment was delivered on Wednesday by a bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta, who ordered that any amount already deposited or recovered from Amazon must be refunded within eight weeks.
Amazon had contested the penalty, arguing that it had not suppressed any material details when seeking approval for its 2019 investment in Future Coupons. The investment case, which dates back to 2019, involved Amazon securing a significant stake in FCPL, an entity closely associated with Future Retail Limited (FRL). The CCI had been informed that Amazon was acquiring the 49% stake in FCPL as part of its strategy to enhance FCPL’s gift card, loyalty card, and payment services business.
The CCI had initially given its nod to the transaction on November 28, 2019, assessing that the deal would not adversely affect market competition in India. However, the approval was contingent upon the accuracy of the information provided by Amazon, stipulating that any misrepresentation could lead to revocation.
The matter escalated when CCI scrutinized Amazon’s internal communications. According to these documents, Amazon’s true intention extended beyond FCPL’s gift card business to gaining a strategic hold in Future Retail and the broader offline retail market in India. The documents referenced ‘Project Taj,’ which included Future Retail’s store network, ultra-fast delivery in major Indian cities, and the possibility of expanding Amazon’s stake contingent on changes in foreign investment laws.
CCI concluded that Amazon had not disclosed the full scope and intent of its deal with FCPL. It identified that the shareholders’ agreement with FRL and commercial dealings between Amazon and Future group entities were interconnected, yet not fully revealed. CCI claimed that Amazon had misrepresented FCPL’s business potential as the primary motivation for the investment, while internal records indicated it was a tactical move to gain strategic rights over FRL.
More Read
On December 17, 2021, CCI suspended its prior approval of the Amazon-Future deal, instructing Amazon to resubmit its notification in Form II. The commission also imposed the ₹202 crore penalty under Sections 43A, 44, and 45 of the Competition Act for improper notification, false declarations, and suppression of critical information.
Amazon’s appeal against this ruling before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) resulted in the tribunal largely affirming CCI’s findings. The NCLAT ruled that Amazon had failed to provide adequate information regarding the deal and upheld the penalty under Section 43A, mandating payment within 45 days.
Representing Amazon were Senior Advocates Gopal Subramanium and Arvind Varma, along with a legal team including Advocates Anand Swarup Pathak, Shashank Gautam, and others. The CCI’s legal representation was led by Additional Solicitor General N Venkataraman, supported by Advocates Sanyat Lodha, Manu Chaturvedi, and others.
